The Energy Efficiency First principle (EE1st) underpins current EU energy policy. It requires that, before investing in energy supply, decision makers should assess whether demand-side resources or system flexibility could achieve the same objective more cost-effectively. Applied to residential buildings, this means that renovation support should first considering reducing energy demand, and only then address the replacement of the heat source.
National renovation subsidy schemes across the Member States are, in most cases, built on formal eligibility criteria. They establish what a project must contain, but they rarely differentiate projects by quality or by genuine life-cycle economic value. The consequence is a risk of funding investments that are formally correct yet poorly justified in cost terms – and, in the cases our pilot examined, of directing the highest support rates to the variants delivering the weakest energy outcomes.
The second pilot case done in Poland for the ENEFIRST Plus’ project has developed a scoring layer designed to address this. The methodology operates alongside existing formal criteria without amending the rules of renovation programmes. It includes three weighted components – EE1st Score (40%), Financial Accessibility Score (35%) and System Impact Score (25%) – complemented by a bounded recognition of non-energy benefits. It has been validated on a reference single-family building and stress-tested against a counter-case in the multi-family segment.
This workshop focused on the main results from this Polish pilot case, with discussions on the link with Cost-Benefit Analysis methodologies, and shared complementary experiences from Ireland and the Netherlands.
Presentations
- Welcome and short introduction about implementing the EE1st principle in the residential sector by Sam Thomas, RAP
- Quality scoring to implement EE1st in renovation subsidies: main results from the Polish pilot case by Hanna Pilzak (KAPE, Poland)
- Guiding investments in building renovation: the Irish experience by Stephen Farrell (SEAI, Ireland)
- Accelerating sustainability in the build environment: the Dutch experience by Joost Hartlief (RVO, the Netherlands)
Recording